Blogger Template by Blogcrowds

Texas Sex Ed: MAJOR FAIL

Originally posted (by me) over at Amplify Your Voice:

A new report out of the Lone Star State tells it like it is: in the state that gets the most federal abstinence-only money, only 4% of school districts teach responsible information about preventing pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections.

Of the other 96%, 2% choose to teach absolutely nothing at all, while the rest use programs and tactics of the "abstinence clowns" including using program materials with factual inaccuracies about condoms and contraceptives, generalizations based on stereotypes about gender and sexual orientation, and religious messaging that violates constitutional statutes.

The report, based on materials gathered from over 1000 Texas school districts, goes into shocking detail about exactly what young people are being told about sex, contraception and their bodies.

One skit titled "Jumping Off the Bridge" concludes: Giving a condom to a teen is just like saying, "Well if you insist on killing yourself by jumping off the bridge, at least wear these elbow pads - they may protect you some?"

Another presenter inexplicalby equates pre-marital sex with post-marital murder-suicides, while yet another compares male sexual desire with a microwave and female sexual desire with a crockpot. Huh?

Texas has the third highest teen birth rate in the nation and individual cities consistently rank among the highest in rates of teen sexually transmitted infections. While governors of 25 states have rejected abstinence-only funds because the programs have been proven not to work, Texas remains staunchly behind the times.

Unfortunately, Texas' abysmal lack of sex ed has national implications.Textbook publishers that self-censor health information to snag the ab-only market in Texas don't reprint different material for every smaller state, spreading the fear and misinformation far and wide.

The report makes several recommendations for the state, including the rejection of abstinence-only-until-marriage funds and the adoption of program material that includes non-biased, medically accurate information, as well as increased oversight of sex education curricula.

17 Comments:

  1. Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby, I teach Women Studies in New Hampshire and have shown your film now for three years in a row! I'm hoping to have my students post a comment at your blog as part of a homework assignment in response to your film. Hope that's okay with you. Thanks.
    Ms. C at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hi Shelby, I think what you are doing is great! I find it appalling that Texas continues to support and abstinence-only policy even though they have one of the highest pregnancy rates in the country. I feel bad for the students in Texas because I could not imagine being fed inaccurate information. I think you are very brave for fighting not only for sex education at your old high school in Lubbock, but also for the GAP group as well. I enjoyed your movie, and thought it was really interesting to see what life is like for a teenager in Texas because coming from a considerably liberal town in New England, the education is obviously much different. I think your fight for sex education is very admirable. Thanks!

    Courtney* at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby! I really enjoyed watching your movie and i learned a lot about Texas and how different it is to be a teenager there. I have no problem with teenagers deciding to be abstinent but teens need to know other alternatives. Teaching abstinence only is not enough information to keep teens safe and out of trouble. This is made very clear by the rate of teen pregnancy in Texas. What you did at Lubbock High School was great! Teenagers should know about condoms and birth control and sexually transmitted infections, and they should know the truth. I also liked the fight for GAP as well. We have a Gay Straight Alliance Club at our school and it was definitely a shock for our class to see the way that homosexuals are treated in other parts of the country. I loved the movie and think you're great! Thank you!

    - Meg D. KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby! I think that you standing up for something you believe in like sex education knowning that you are going to have to deal with ALOT of crap was really great and very brave of you! i am with you 110% on this i think that they should definitly have sex education in schools so that there are less teen pregnant. i think that having just the abstinence- only program is just going to make them wanting to have sex even more to find out all the stuff no one will tell them. Also ithink it was really brave of you to stand up for other peoples believes even if there not exactly something that you perticipate in, like the whole gay straight alliance. we watched you movie in our womens studies class and after watching what you had to go through from everyone and still not giving up i think makes you a Very good person. i also hope that my teacher continues to show your film so that people can really understand what people have to go throught to get stuff to get things that people always thought they had, i mean i had a type of sex ed class and it deffinitly helped me alot! i hope that one day they will see it your way and start educating the teens.
    thank you and keep up the good work!
    Kayla <3 at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hi Shelby! My Women's Studies class watched your video and I think what you're doing and what you did is awesome. Where I come from, sex education is available to everyone. I couldn't imagine growing up not having that in our schools. I find it very shocking that Lubbock still stands by the abstinence-only policy after having the third highest teen pregnancy rate in the nation and after everything you and your classmates went through trying to change it. On your part, I think you did a great job fighting for sex education in your high school. I really liked watching your movie and learning about what the life of a teen in Lubbock, Texas may be like. I hope that Lubbock changes their policy in the near future because they may see some changes Keep doing what you're doing!!

    Stephanie :) at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hello Shelby! I watched your film in my Womens Studies class, as we are learning about reproductive rights and sexual education. I was so shocked because I was very unaware of the lack of sex ed in the south! After viewing your film I realized it was absolutely devastating that students are being completely misinformed about sex. It blows my mind that Texas is strongly for abstinence only when it comes to sex, while they have such a high teen preganancy rate! It is sad and seems so incredibly unfair to the teens of Texas because sex is such a natural thing which everyone deserves to be educated about. I have so much admitarion for you and your fight for sex education at Lubbock High School. It must have taken you a lot of courage, heart, and drive. It is greatly appreciated and I think that you are so correct about all of your points and reasonings for why sex education needs to be taught in schools. Your film taught me a lot about the lifestyle of teens in Lubbock and how it is so different from here. I actually, for once, appreciate and am grateful for health class because I know it is accurate information. Thank You so very muchj for what you are doing and what you stand for! Goodluck and don't give up!

    Mk at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby, In my Women Studies class we watched your film. I think what you are doing is wonderful. I can't even believe that Texas, despite it being third highest pregnancy rates in the nation, still goes by abstinence-only. How can they be so blind to such a big problem. I think you are very brave in your journey to change the ways in Texas, and helping out the GAP group. I couldn't even imagine being fed such inaccurate information about sex. If you are not supposed to have sex until you are married, and not learn about any STD's or the consequences, how are you supposed to know once married, if you are only fed false information.
    I think you are brave, and I support everything you are doing, don't give up!!

    Courtney :) at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby, I think you are doing a great job! I think Texas needs to change their abstinence- only policies. I agree that abstinence is an important aspect of sex education, but I think that high school students need to hear it all! Students need to be provided with the information to make their own decisions. It is absolutely inappropriate for inaccurate information to be taught. I think that with the high pregnancy rate, Texas needs to change their attitude about sex education. I think that you are doing an amazing thing and should continue to fight for what you believe in! I really enjoyed watching your film and learned a lot from it! Thanks
    KR at KHS
    Anonymous said...
    It is shocking that the sexual education of Texas' youth is so far behind. As a developed nation whose founding principles include freedom of speech, and the separation of church and state, the sheer notion that teaching abstinence-only with a religious background flies in the face of the philosophies that the American Revolution was fought over. In addition to the moral aspect, which defies the wishes of the founding fathers, is the scientific factor. The United States is a nation that prides itself on the curiosity of its people, and satisfying that curiosity with analytical, scientifically-based facts. The obscure content of the abstinence-only program provides the students with falsified information that only contributes more to the foggy cloud of knowledge that is the base of the sexual education program in Lubbock and various other parts of Texas. Though abstinence can, and most certainly should be, taught as part of the curriculum, it should only be a part, and not the whole of the class. Amendments to the sexual education program are direct ways to target the high rates of teen pregnancy. As other states have acknowledged, an abstinence-only program does not provide students with the information that they need, especially should they choose to engage in sexual activity. However, it is critical to the success of this fight for the abolition of abstinence-only programs throughout the nation, that those in power and those behind the programs realize that by educating their youth to the fullest extent, does not mean that they are enabling, or condoning, the engagement of sexual activity. In such a day and age when the media throws sexual promiscuity in the faces of its viewers, it is important for all involved to realize the true value of an accurate sexual education program. No doubt has your voice, as well as the release of "The Education of Shelby Knox" film, contributed greatly to raising awareness. In a society where the freedom of speech is just that, a freedom, it is important to speak up for individual beliefs, such as you are doing, with the goal of changing the thoughts, or practices, of a people for the further development of the education of those people.
    --SB
    Anonymous said...
    Hi Shelby, I think what you are doing is good . irls need to know how to protect themselves so they wont get pregnant. Texas continues to have the third highest teen pregnancy rates because teen girls don't know how to protect themselves.
    I think that your fight for Sex Education in your school is a very brave thing to do.
    I found your film to be very interesing and it taught me a lot about safe sex. I admire your fighting spirit.
    Kc
    Anonymous said...
    Hi Shelby, I just want to tell you that what you are doing is really brave and so important. My women's study class watched you video and I have to say I think we were all shocked. I honestly cannot believe that schools in Texas don't encourage sex education, especially when the state has the 3rd highest pregnancy rate in the nation. You would think that more people would be against the abstinence-only police with in schools today because times have changed!! I'm sure that there are teenage's and adults who are devoted to abstinence until marriage, but what about the ones that don't; teens need to be taught sex education. I think what you did for GAP was amazing too, because I feel whether you gay, bi, transsexual, or straight, we are all people. I loved you movie.
    Keep it up.
    Ashley KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hi Shelby,
    I am from the Women's Studies class in New Hampshire. I was amazed when I watched the movie you made. It ts so hard for me to imagine the idea that sex education is not a part of school. I am from a very libral town in NH and feel like sex education has been a very important part of my education. I believe that it should be taught nation wide. I really admire your fight. It's not easy to fight againt people that feel as strongly as they do in Lubbock. I also really admire your work with the GAP kids. I never thought of those two issues being related but now I understand it much more.

    Thank you for a great movie and all the work that you do!

    ~Angelika KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby, I loved watching your movie!! At first i really didnt know what to expect form the movie, but i had know idea that the sex education was this bad in Texas. Life in Texas as a teenager is very different and i was surprised on how little information the school provides.Even though the schools policy is Abstinence-Only the teachers must be blind becasue look around, most of the girls at Lubbock high school are either pregnant or having unprotected sex.Its not fair to the students to not have Sex Education at there school. If i didnt know what i know today my life would be compelety different, as for most girls in high school. I think what your doing is very brave and takes alot of guts to stand up for you believe in. I think if there were more girls like you at Lubbock high school fighting for Sex Education then somthing would deffiently change. Keep up your hard work, because what your doing is going to help a alot of girls down the road.
    Amber.L KHS
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby.
    I think what u are doing is very goood. This country needs someone like you to stick up for their classmates and their school. u sould deff continue to do what u are doing beacause i know a lot of girls appricaite it. I loved your film, i thought it was pretty amazing, and loved to see someone soo young do what u did. i think its sad how the school doesnt look around and see all the girls pregnant, or the kids having unprotected sex, they souldnt have a problem teaching sex ed. I think your a great person , keep up the good work, thanks!!
    *Elizabeth*
    Anonymous said...
    I think that you are doing a great job with standing up for what you believe in. however i think girls should have the option to get educated about sex ed. I think you did a fantastic job with your fight for sex education.
    Thanks.
    Kerri R.
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby.
    I think somebody really needs to realize that teaching abstinence-only is NOT working. Kids are going to experiment with sex, it's what our minds and bodies want to do, and if we're not taught at least how to be safe, then you're not going to be. And that's why places that teach this have the highest teen pregnancy rates. I think everything you said and everything you fought for at Lubbock High School, someone really should have listened and taken everything you said into consideration, and changed how things are done. In New Hampshire we get a good amount of information and it's right information. And I would no be able to handle the amount of inaccurate information they tell you down there. If they're going to continue teaching abstinence-only then they should at least have some correct information.
    I love everything you're fighting for, and i hope a lot changes from your efforts.
    -cbw at khs
    Anonymous said...
    Hey Shelby!


    I too watched your movie in Women's Studies at KHS. I to find it appalling that, regardless of the fact that it is NOT helping, that school boards still decide to teach abstinence-only "sex education".

    I think that in both your post and the movie, that the hardest part for me was the blatant lies fed to these children.

    -God loves homosexuals as much as he loves murderers.
    -STD's are spread from hand-to-hand contact
    -etc, etc.

    It is one thing to teach abstinence only in schools. While I don’t agree with it, and find it ineffective, it is their prerogative.
    On the other hand, feeding children and teens lies about sex, or any interaction with the opposite sex in general, is horrifying to me!
    This does nothing beneficial for the kids in this situation, as they need to find the "real" information somehow, and will experiment to learn a lesson.

    Im so frustrated with this, so I cannot imagine how you must feel.

    -Kim (KHS)

Post a Comment



Newer Post Older Post Home